RR873 - Beryllium: A review of the health effects and the evidence for screening or surveillance in workers exposed to beryllium
As exposure limits for beryllium have decreased, so has the incidence and severity of chronic beryllium disease.
There are however an emerging number of cases of subclinical disease and beryllium sensitization (BeS)
that are being detected with new immunological tests, namely the beryllium lymphocyte proliferation
test (BeLPT). Almost all the recent data on screening beryllium workers relates to the BeLPT, and more
traditional screening programmes such as spirometry and chest x-rays that have been in use since the
1950s have only been evaluated as secondary endpoints.
Whilst the BeLPT has revolutionised the diagnosis of chronic beryllium disease (CBD), concerns have been
raised about its inter- and intra-laboratory variability, possible reversibility in patients and uncertain sensitivity
and specificity. There is also debate about the natural history of BeS and subclinical CBD and the ethical
aspects of identifying disease early when there is no treatment, and subsequent employment implications.
Another issue for the UK is the fact that only one laboratory offers BeLPT testing, although certain evidence
supports double sampling of tests across laboratories to improve sensitivity and specificity. All these factors
have led to certain US based groups advocating the use of BeLPT for screening and others not.
Therefore, in the US, a definitive stance on the content of a health surveillance programme has not been
possible from the current evidence base. This is supported by the fact, for example, that the National
Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), whilst citing many articles on beryllium on its website,
does not offer any specific advice on health surveillance in beryllium workers, as it does for other industries.
This report and the work it describes were funded by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE). Its contents,
including any opinions and/or conclusions expressed, are those of the authors alone and do not necessarily
reflect HSE policy.
Assistance in the use of Adobe Acrobat PDF files is available on our FAQs page.